1
of 6— Define your comparison criteria before opening Claude
What you'll accomplish
Use Claude to extract and compare key data from benefits carrier renewal proposals: medical, dental, vision, or voluntary benefits. Instead of spending a full day building a comparison matrix from 3–4 proposals, you'll have a structured executive summary in under an hour.
What you'll need
- Claude Pro subscription ({{tool:Claude.price}}/month) for PDF uploads
- The carrier proposals as PDFs (1 per carrier; page count varies, usually 15–40 pages each)
- A list of the comparison criteria your leadership cares about (premiums, network, out-of-pocket costs, etc.)
- Time needed: 30–45 minutes total for 3–4 proposals
- Cost: {{tool:Claude.price}}/month
How-To Guide: Summarize and Compare Benefits Carrier Proposals
Step 1: Define your comparison criteria before opening Claude
Write a quick list of what matters for this decision. For medical renewals, this typically includes:
- Monthly employer and employee premiums by plan tier (single/EE+1/family)
- Deductible and out-of-pocket maximum
- HSA/HRA eligibility
- Network type (HMO, PPO, HDHP) and size
- Key covered services differences (mental health, fertility, telehealth)
- Admin fee / PEPM charges
- Financial guarantees or risk corridors
Having this list before you start makes your prompts more targeted.
Tools:Claude